NEW JERSEY WORKERS' COMPENSATION
WE HAVE YOUR BACK

WATCH OUR VIDEO

Determining New Jersey Jurisdiction for a Work Injury Case

Table of Contents

Jurisdiction—This essential term determines whether you can bring a work injury claim in New Jersey. In essence, jurisdiction is the legal green light, a necessary prerequisite for filing. If New Jersey has jurisdiction over your work injury claim, you can receive the work injury benefits allowable under state law.

Dictionary open to the definition of Jurisdiction in NJ Workers’ Compensation law reflecting key work injury concept

What’s Jurisdiction Anyway?

Imagine a grand library, where each room represents a state in the United States. The California room is filled with books about California’s laws and stories, the Texas room has its unique collection, and so on for every state. Now, suppose you have a story (or a legal case) that happened in New Jersey. You’d naturally start in the New Jersey room to understand or decide about that story because that’s where it belongs.

However, there are special circumstances where you need to step into another room, even if the story takes place in New Jersey. Some characters in your story are from Pennsylvania, or there’s a twist that ties to New York. While these scenarios can get complex, the New Jersey room is still your best starting point.

Jurisdiction is this guiding principle that helps you determine the right room (or state court) for your story. Just as you wouldn’t normally read about a Florida event in the New York room, you wouldn’t typically bring a legal case to a state where it doesn’t belong.

In our world of work injuries, it’s like figuring out which room in the grand library to step into. Should you open the book of New Jersey’s workers’ comp rules for your injury story, or does it belong in another state’s collection?

Where you bring your case (or tell your story) has a big impact on the success of your case (or the ending to your story).  Choose wisely, and know that starting in the right place can make all the difference.

In our world of work injuries, it’s like figuring out which room in the grand library to step into. Should you open the book of New Jersey’s workers’ comp rules for your injury story, or does it belong in another state’s collection?

The Two Big Questions

Where did the Injury Happen?

Lets imagine Lisa from Lakewood, NJ, who is employed by a New Jersey company that makes widgets in Delran.   Lisa is injured while on the job at the company manufacturing plant in Delran.  If you get hurt in New Jersey, as Lisa did, you’re in the right place to use New Jersey’s workers’ comp rules.

But, if you get injured in, say, New York or Pennsylvania while working for a New Jersey company, things might get tricky.

Who's Your Boss?

If the company you work for is based in New Jersey or does a lot of its business here, you might still be under New Jersey rules, even if your accident wasn’t in the state.

Now, back to Lisa. She got injured in New Jersey and works for a New Jersey company. So, it’s looking good for her to claim benefits here.

What Should Lisa Do Next?

  • Report the Injury: The first thing Lisa should do is tell her boss about her injury, right away.

 

  • Seek Medical Attention: Health comes first. Lisa should see a doctor, even if she thinks it’s a minor injury.

 

  • Keep Records: Lisa should save any paperwork or receipts related to her injury, medical visits, and the accident.

Key Factors for New Jersey Jurisdiction

Understanding the Challenges

Jurisdiction is a tricky path to walk, especially in New Jersey. Our state has its own set of rules, unique from our neighbors. On top of that, federal laws sometimes dance with our state laws, making the rhythm of workers’ comp even more intricate.

When New Jersey's Jurisdiction Applies

Tom worked for a company headquartered in New York but was hired while he was living in New Jersey. One day, while working from home, a heavy shelf in his home office collapsed on him. Where should Tom file his workers’ comp claim? Since his employment contract was made in New Jersey and the injury occurred there, he has a strong ground to file in New Jersey. It’s key to know that New Jersey can be the right place if the contract was made, the injury happened, or it’s your main work hub.

Change the facts, however, and different results can emerge.  Airline employees can find their hub in the Newark International Airport, one of the country’s largest airports.  In a work injury case, the New Jersey Superior could hold that the employer’s presence in New Jersey and the residency of the injured worker in New Jersey were insufficient to grant jurisdiction over a work injury claim.   Pennsylvania served as the site of the work injury and where the injured worker performed work duties.     

An injured worker just leaving a hospital and entering a scene of natural beauty outside upon full recovery from a work injury

Overcoming Common Misconceptions

Tales are swirling around – myths about where you can and can’t file for workers’ comp. Let’s address some of the most common misconceptions head-on:

  1. “I was injured outside New Jersey, so I can’t file here.”

Truth: Even if you were injured outside the state, if your principal place of employment is in New Jersey, or if your employment contract was made here, you might still be eligible to file a claim in New Jersey.

  1. “My company isn’t based in New Jersey, so I can’t file a claim here.”

Truth: The location of your company’s headquarters isn’t the only factor. As mentioned before, where the contract was made and where the injury occurred can also play a pivotal role in determining jurisdiction.

  1. “If I file in New Jersey, I can’t file anywhere else.”

Truth: While it’s typically not advisable to file multiple claims in different states, there are complex scenarios where multiple jurisdictions might be involved. However, getting legal guidance before making such decisions is essential to avoid pitfalls.

  1. “New Jersey’s workers’ comp rules are too strict; I won’t qualify.”

Truth: Every state has its own set of rules and regulations, but that doesn’t mean New Jersey is inherently stricter. Many workers find that New Jersey’s laws are quite protective and beneficial for injured workers.

Infographic Summary of Article

Helpful key information for workers on How New Jersey determines jurisdiction for a work injury case.

"No man is above the law and no man is below it; nor do we ask any man's permission when we require him to obey it. Obedience to the law is demanded as a right; not asked as a favor."

A Room with a View to Recovery

Navigating the complex corridors of workers’ compensation can often feel like wandering through a vast library, unsure of where to turn or which room to enter. But just as every great story finds its rightful place on the shelves, every injured worker deserves to find the best possible ending to their own story of injury to recovery.

With its robust workers’ compensation system, New Jersey offers not just pages but entire chapters of support, protection, and benefits designed for the recovery of injured workers. From comprehensive medical coverage to legal protections, Garden State stands out among other states.  

Yet, every story is unique, and each claim has its nuances. Understanding which ‘room’ your story belongs to, busting myths, and ensuring you receive all entitled benefits can be daunting.

For over 25 years, New Jersey work injury lawyer John F. Renner has championed the rights of the injured, ensuring they aren’t just another number but are treated with the care and respect they deserve. Choose an attorney that offers the best path forward for your unique circumstances.

About the Author

About the Author

John F. Renner is the founding attorney and principal of John F. Renner P.C. He has more than 25 years of experience representing injured workers in New Jersey. Mr. Renner guides his clients through the complex maze of New Jersey Workers Compensation Law for the best possible outcome.

Read More...

Share This Story. Choose Your Platform.